Evaluating Peter Schiff’s Claim: Is Bitcoin a “Total Scam”?

1. Executive Summary:

Peter Schiff, a well-known economist and long-time advocate for gold, has consistently voiced strong criticism against Bitcoin, frequently labeling it a speculative bubble and, more recently, a “total scam”. This report aims to evaluate the validity of Schiff’s assertion by examining his core arguments against Bitcoin in light of current data and counter-arguments presented by proponents and the broader market. While acknowledging the inherent risks and volatility associated with Bitcoin, this analysis will explore its evolving legitimacy, adoption, and real-world applications to determine if the “total scam” label accurately reflects the current state of affairs.

2. Peter Schiff’s “Total Scam” Claim: An In-Depth Look:

Peter Schiff’s condemnation of Bitcoin as a “total scam” is underpinned by several key arguments that he has reiterated over the years. A central tenet of his criticism is the assertion that Bitcoin lacks intrinsic value, unlike traditional assets such as gold. Schiff frequently contrasts Bitcoin with gold, which he views as a tangible asset with a long history as a store of value and possessing inherent utility beyond monetary purposes, such as in electronics and jewelry. This traditional economic perspective struggles to find inherent value in a purely digital asset, leading to skepticism about its long-term viability.

Furthermore, Schiff consistently characterizes Bitcoin as a speculative bubble destined to burst, often comparing it to historical financial manias like the tulip bubble. He argues that Bitcoin’s price appreciation is driven by speculation and the “fear of missing out” (FOMO), rather than fundamental value or widespread utility. In line with this, he has repeatedly likened Bitcoin to a Ponzi scheme, suggesting that its rising price is contingent on a continuous influx of new investors, with early adopters profiting at the expense of those who buy in later. This perspective emphasizes the potential for significant losses for investors when the speculative fervor eventually subsides.

Another key argument from Schiff is that Bitcoin has failed to become a widely adopted medium of exchange in the real world and has not fundamentally changed daily life for most people. He points out that despite being around for over a decade, Bitcoin’s practical use in everyday transactions remains limited compared to traditional currencies or even established digital payment systems. This lack of widespread adoption in commerce, according to Schiff, further undermines its claim to be a legitimate currency or store of value.

Over the years, Schiff has consistently predicted the imminent collapse of Bitcoin’s price, often forecasting its eventual decline to zero, particularly during times of financial uncertainty. These predictions, while not yet realized, underscore his strong conviction that Bitcoin is fundamentally flawed and unsustainable. More recently, Schiff has suggested that Bitcoin’s resilience and price increases are not due to organic market forces but rather the result of government intervention and manipulation, possibly influenced by a powerful cryptocurrency lobby. This argument attempts to explain Bitcoin’s continued existence and price growth despite his long-standing bearish outlook.

3. The Counter-Narrative: Arguments for Bitcoin’s Legitimacy and Value:

In contrast to Peter Schiff’s view, a significant number of individuals and institutions argue for Bitcoin’s legitimacy and value proposition. One prominent argument positions Bitcoin as “digital gold,” suggesting it serves a similar role as a scarce asset that can store value over time and act as a hedge against inflation. Proponents emphasize Bitcoin’s finite supply of 21 million coins, a characteristic that distinguishes it from fiat currencies, which can be subject to inflationary pressures through central bank policies. This scarcity, coupled with increasing demand, is seen as a fundamental driver of Bitcoin’s value as a long-term store of wealth.

Furthermore, Bitcoin’s adoption and real-world use cases are steadily expanding beyond mere speculation. It is increasingly used for cross-border remittances, offering a potentially cheaper and faster alternative to traditional banking systems. The development and growing adoption of layer-2 scaling solutions like the Lightning Network are enhancing Bitcoin’s capabilities for everyday digital payments by enabling faster transactions with lower fees. Additionally, innovative use cases like energy monetization, where Bitcoin mining is used to utilize stranded energy resources, demonstrate practical applications beyond financial speculation. Bitcoin also plays a role in promoting financial inclusion by providing access to financial services for the unbanked population in various parts of the world. Its decentralized and censorship-resistant nature offers a means of transacting and storing value in environments where traditional financial systems may be unreliable or subject to government control.

The increasing legitimacy of Bitcoin as an investment is evidenced by the emergence of regulated Bitcoin products, such as Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), and the growing interest from institutional investors. The approval of spot Bitcoin ETFs by regulatory bodies like the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has provided traditional investors with a more accessible and regulated way to gain exposure to Bitcoin. This regulatory endorsement and the entry of established financial institutions into the Bitcoin space lend credibility to its status as a legitimate asset class. Even Peter Schiff’s own asset management firm was recently found to have indirect exposure to Bitcoin through a Bitcoin-backed bond, highlighting the growing integration of Bitcoin into traditional finance.

Underlying Bitcoin’s value is its groundbreaking blockchain technology, which offers a decentralized, secure, and transparent system for recording and verifying transactions. The strength of Bitcoin’s network, characterized by its increasing number of users, further enhances its value through network effects – the more people use it, the more valuable it becomes. This fundamental technology and its expanding user base contribute to Bitcoin’s intrinsic value beyond mere speculative trading.

4. Bitcoin in Numbers: Adoption Rates and Market Capitalization:

The growing acceptance and integration of Bitcoin can be further illustrated by examining its adoption rates and market capitalization. Current estimates suggest that between 422 and 455 million people globally own Bitcoin, representing approximately 5% of the world’s population. While this is still a relatively small percentage, it signifies a substantial and increasing level of mainstream interest in the digital asset. Cryptocurrency ownership in general has surged, with over 824 million people owning some form of digital asset. Adoption rates vary across different regions, with countries like the UAE, Singapore, and Turkey showing higher percentages of their populations owning cryptocurrencies. In the United States, approximately 28% of adults, or about 65 million people, owned cryptocurrencies in 2025, a significant increase from 15% in 2021.

Bitcoin’s market capitalization, which represents the total value of all Bitcoin in circulation, stands at approximately $1.92 trillion as of May 7, 2025. This multi-trillion dollar valuation signifies a substantial amount of capital invested in Bitcoin and reflects the market’s overall perception of its value. Bitcoin also holds a dominant position in the cryptocurrency market, accounting for around 67% of the total crypto market capitalization.

The following table summarizes key Bitcoin adoption metrics:

This data indicates that Bitcoin is far from a negligible entity and has garnered significant adoption and market valuation, suggesting a level of legitimacy that contradicts the notion of it being a “total scam.”

5. Beyond Speculation: Real-World Use Cases of Bitcoin:

While Peter Schiff emphasizes the lack of real-world utility, Bitcoin is finding increasing applications in various sectors. In the realm of remittances, Bitcoin offers a compelling alternative to traditional services by enabling cheaper and faster cross-border money transfers. Its peer-to-peer nature can bypass intermediaries, reducing fees and settlement times, which is particularly beneficial for individuals sending money to family members in other countries.

The use of Bitcoin for digital payments is also gaining traction, especially with the advancements in scaling solutions like the Lightning Network. The Lightning Network allows for near-instant microtransactions with minimal fees, making Bitcoin a more viable option for everyday purchases. While widespread adoption in traditional retail is still evolving, an increasing number of online merchants and service providers are beginning to accept Bitcoin as a form of payment.

An innovative use case is the monetization of energy, where Bitcoin mining operations are deployed to utilize stranded or wasted energy sources that would otherwise go unused. This can include excess power from renewable energy projects or flare gas from oil drilling, turning a potential waste product into a revenue stream. Examples like the use of hydroelectric power in Virunga National Park for conservation funding illustrate the positive impact of this application.

Bitcoin also plays a crucial role in promoting financial inclusion by providing access to financial services for individuals who are unbanked or underbanked. In regions with limited access to traditional banking infrastructure or where fiat currencies are unstable, Bitcoin offers an alternative means of storing and transferring value using just a smartphone and an internet connection.

Furthermore, Bitcoin’s decentralized and censorship-resistant nature provides a valuable tool for individuals seeking financial freedom and security, particularly in countries with political or economic instability. Transactions on the Bitcoin network are transparent and recorded on a public ledger, yet they can be pseudonymous, offering a degree of privacy while resisting censorship from governments or financial institutions.

Beyond these established use cases, Bitcoin’s underlying technology is also enabling new and emerging applications, such as in smart contracts, Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs), and potentially as a reserve asset for corporations and even nation-states. These developments indicate the evolving utility of Bitcoin and its potential to disrupt various industries beyond just traditional finance.

6. Historical Performance and Volatility: Contextualizing the Risks:

Bitcoin’s price history has been marked by significant volatility, a factor often highlighted by critics like Peter Schiff. Since its inception, Bitcoin has experienced periods of rapid price appreciation followed by substantial corrections. For instance, after its initial introduction in 2009 at virtually no value, Bitcoin saw its first major price surge in 2011, reaching nearly $30 before crashing back down. Similar cycles of boom and bust have occurred throughout its history, with notable peaks in 2013, 2017, 2021, and 2024, followed by significant drawdowns. In late 2024 and early 2025, Bitcoin reached new all-time highs, exceeding $100,000 on several exchanges.

Analysis of Bitcoin’s volatility shows that it has historically been significantly higher than that of traditional assets like gold and equities. However, some data suggests a trend of decreasing volatility as the Bitcoin market matures and attracts more institutional participation. Comparisons with the volatility of certain mega-cap technology stocks also indicate that Bitcoin’s volatility, while still elevated, is not entirely unprecedented in the broader market. Factors contributing to Bitcoin’s price swings include market sentiment, regulatory developments, macroeconomic conditions, and the supply and demand dynamics in what is still a relatively nascent market.

The following table showcases some of Bitcoin’s historical price milestones:

This historical performance demonstrates the potential for significant returns but also highlights the inherent risks associated with Bitcoin’s price volatility.

7. Recent Developments and Peter Schiff’s Evolving (or Consistent) Stance:

Peter Schiff has remained steadfast in his criticism of Bitcoin, recently reiterating his view that it is a “total scam”. He continues to predict its eventual failure, suggesting that the financial crisis of 2025 will be the catalyst for its demise. Schiff argues that Bitcoin lacks real market value and its current price is artificially inflated by government-driven money flows. He maintains his belief that gold remains the only true safe haven asset.

Despite his consistently negative public stance, there have been developments that introduce a degree of nuance to Schiff’s position. Notably, it was revealed that Euro Pacific Asset Management, a firm managed by Schiff, held a Bitcoin-backed bond in late 2024. This indirect exposure to Bitcoin, even as Schiff publicly denounces it, suggests a potential disconnect between his rhetoric and the investment strategies of his firm. While Schiff may not have personally directed this specific investment, it indicates a growing recognition of Bitcoin’s relevance within the broader financial landscape, even among those who are publicly critical.

The cryptocurrency community has largely dismissed Peter Schiff’s criticisms as outdated or biased. Crypto experts often counter his arguments by pointing to Bitcoin’s increasing adoption, its resilience through multiple market cycles, and its growing legitimacy within the financial system. They argue that Schiff’s focus on gold reflects a traditional mindset that fails to appreciate the disruptive potential and unique characteristics of digital assets like Bitcoin. When Bitcoin surpassed $100,000 in December 2024, Schiff attributed it to government intervention, a claim that was quickly refuted by members of the crypto community who emphasized Bitcoin’s organic growth and resilience.

8. Conclusion: Evaluating the “Total Scam” Claim:

Evaluating Peter Schiff’s claim that Bitcoin is a “total scam” requires a comprehensive consideration of the evidence. While Schiff raises valid concerns about Bitcoin’s price volatility and the potential for speculative bubbles, labeling it a “total scam” appears to be an oversimplification of a complex and rapidly evolving asset. The evidence presented in this report indicates that Bitcoin has moved beyond its early speculative phase and is demonstrating increasing adoption, diverse real-world use cases, and growing acceptance within the traditional financial system.

Bitcoin’s emergence as a potential digital store of value, its increasing use for remittances and digital payments, its innovative applications in areas like energy monetization and financial inclusion, and the rising interest from institutional investors all suggest that it plays a significant role in the future financial landscape. While the historical price volatility and inherent risks associated with cryptocurrency investments cannot be ignored, the underlying technological innovation, the expanding network effects, and the increasing regulatory clarity point towards a level of legitimacy that contradicts the “total scam” assertion.

In conclusion, while caution and thorough research are undoubtedly necessary for anyone considering investing in Bitcoin, the evidence suggests that it is more accurately viewed as a novel and disruptive asset with both significant opportunities and challenges, rather than a complete and utter deception. Peter Schiff’s long-standing skepticism, rooted in traditional economic principles, may not fully account for the evolving nature of value and the transformative potential of decentralized digital currencies in the 21st century.

Works cited

1. Peter Schiff: Bitcoin Adds No Value? #crypto #bitcoin #investing – YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t0oH4hjMwqk 2. Bitcoin Daily: Crypto Scammers’ Daily Haul Drops 66 Pct Due To COVID-19 – PYMNTS.com, https://www.pymnts.com/blockchain/bitcoin/2020/bitcoin-daily-crypto-scammers-daily-haul-drops-66-pct-due-to-covid-19-atbcoin-to-settle-ico-suit-for-250000-gold-investor-peter-schiff-predicts-bitcoin-fall/ 3. Economist Peter Schiff Predicts Bitcoin’s End In 2025 Financial Crisis – Outlook Money, https://www.outlookmoney.com/cryptocurrency/economist-peter-schiff-predicts-bitcoins-end-in-2025-financial-crisis 4. Who is Peter Schiff? – Bitstamp, https://www.bitstamp.net/en-gb/learn/people-profiles/peter-schiff/ 5. Peter Schiff – Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Schiff 6. Peter Schiff mocks Bitcoin’s 7% drop — ‘Punxsutawney Phil was right’ – TheStreet Crypto, https://www.thestreet.com/crypto/markets/peter-schiff-mocks-bitcoins-7-drop-punxsutawney-phil-was-right 7. Bitcoin Hits $103K, But Peter Schiff Is Unimpressed: ‘Without …, https://www.thestreet.com/crypto/markets/bitcoin-hits-103k-but-peter-schiff-is-unimpressed 8. ‘Total Scam’: Peter Schiff Issues Brutal Bitcoin Verdict By U.Today – Investing.com India, https://in.investing.com/news/cryptocurrency-news/total-scam-peter-schiff-issues-brutal-bitcoin-verdict-4812211 9. Peter Schiff Says Crypto ‘Starting to Crack’ as Markets Slide on Trump Tariffs – Decrypt, https://decrypt.co/313579/peter-schiff-crypto-starting-crack-markets-slide-trump-tariffs 10. Peter Schiff warns Bitcoin bubble burst will hit Americans hardest, cites U.S as home to the most powerful crypto lobby; here’s what all he said – The Economic Times, https://m.economictimes.com/news/international/us/peter-schiff-warns-bitcoin-bubble-burst-will-hit-americans-hardest-cites-u-s-as-home-to-the-most-powerful-crypto-lobby-heres-what-all-he-said/articleshow/119015186.cms 11. Peter Schiff On Why Bitcoin Can NEVER Be Real Money – YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JapKX6784Dk 12. Why Crypto Is A Losing Game with Economist Peter Schiff, https://lewishowes.com/podcast/why-crypto-is-a-losing-game-with-economist-peter-schiff/ 13. Bitcoin Expert Peter Schiff Has Bad News For Crypto Enthusiasts – TheStreet, https://www.thestreet.com/crypto/investing/peter-schiff-crypto-tweets 14. 3 Common Criticisms of Crypto—and Why They’re Wrong | Mises …, https://mises.org/power-market/3-common-criticisms-crypto-and-why-theyre-wrong 15. Peter Schiff & Jack Mallers Debate Bitcoin Vs. Gold, Collapse Of Dollar – YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MSlEQA1BoOE 16. Scaramucci Vs Schiff on Bitcoin and Gold [2021] | Intelligence Squared – YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jo0x69zUcCI 17. Bitcoin could potentially become the 21st century gold – Deutsche Bank, https://www.db.com/what-next/digital-disruption/dossier-payments/i-could-potentially-see-bitcoin-to-become-the-21st-century-gold 18. Bitcoin’s value proposition: shorting expansionary monetary policies – Emerald Insight, https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/sef-03-2021-0107/full/html 19. Why does Bitcoin have value? What makes BTC valuable | MoonPay, https://www.moonpay.com/learn/bitcoin/why-does-bitcoin-have-value 20. Is Bitcoin the Future of Money? Peter Schiff vs. Erik Voorhees – YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8R71WGO3qU 21. Peter Schiff talks gold, calls Bitcoin ‘a pure Ponzi’ scheme – YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P-nJYI0Ce8A 22. Peter Schiff’s Strategic Bitcoin Reserve: A Surprising Crypto Pivot – Financial Modeling Prep, https://site.financialmodelingprep.com/market-news/peter-schiffs-strategic-bitcoin-reserve-a-surprising-crypto-pivot 23. Bitcoin vs Gold: EPIC Debate! – YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fpfCB9E-dok 24. Bitcoin vs Gold with Anthony Scaramucci and Peter Schiff – Intelligence Squared, https://www.intelligencesquared.com/events/debate-bitcoin-vs-gold-with-anthony-scaramucci-and-peter-schiff/ 25. The Investment Case for Bitcoin – VanEck, https://www.vaneck.com/us/en/blogs/digital-assets/the-investment-case-for-bitcoin/ 26. An overview of Bitcoin and its potential use cases – Fidelity Digital Assets, https://www.fidelitydigitalassets.com/sites/g/files/djuvja3256/files/acquiadam/FDA%20Bitcoin%20Coin%20Report%20-%2012-06.pdf 27. Why Does Bitcoin Have Value? – Economis, https://economis.com.ar/why-does-bitcoin-have-value/ 28. What Gives Bitcoin Its Value? – Gemini, https://www.gemini.com/cryptopedia/btc-bitcoin-what-gives-it-value-what-gives-bitcoin-its-worth 29. Bitcoin Scarcity and Store-of-Value Attributes – Global X ETFs, https://www.globalxetfs.com/bitcoin-scarcity-and-store-of-value-attributes/ 30. Understanding Bitcoin’s Scarcity and Value Proposition – Easy Crypto, https://hub.easycrypto.com/bitcoin-scarcity-and-value 31. Peter Schiff’s Bitcoin u-turn sparks debate as White House Crypto Summit nears – Mitrade, https://www.mitrade.com/insights/news/live-news/article-3-680142-20250306 32. GOLD VS BITCOIN – Peter Schiff, Michael Oliver & Dominic Frisby – YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9DuhDgqx21w 33. Cryptocurrency adoption surges with over 824 million people …, https://dig.watch/updates/cryptocurrency-adoption-surges-with-over-824-million-people-owning-digital-assets 34. Cryptocurrency Ownership Data – Triple-A, https://www.triple-a.io/cryptocurrency-ownership-data/cryptocurrency-ownership-data 35. 2025 Cryptocurrency Adoption and Consumer Sentiment Report – Security.org, https://www.security.org/digital-security/cryptocurrency-annual-consumer-report/ 36. Cryptocurrency Adoption Statistics and Growth Worldwide – TechGuide, https://techguide.org/fintech/fintech-resources/cryptocurrency-statistics/ 37. The River Bitcoin Adoption Report 2025, https://river.com/learn/files/river-bitcoin-adoption-report-2025.pdf 38. Bitcoin Total User Count – WooCharts, https://woocharts.com/bitcoin-total-users/ 39. The 2023 Global Crypto Adoption Index – Chainalysis, https://www.chainalysis.com/blog/2023-global-crypto-adoption-index/ 40. 2024 Global Crypto Adoption Index – Chainalysis, https://www.chainalysis.com/blog/2024-global-crypto-adoption-index/ 41. 2024 Trends: Crypto Adoption and Illicit Exposure by Country | TRM Insights, https://www.trmlabs.com/post/2024-trends-crypto-adoption-and-illicit-activity-by-country 42. 5 Best Use-Cases for Bitcoin (BTC) – Securities.io, https://www.securities.io/5-best-use-cases-for-bitcoin-btc/ 43. Crypto use cases: 9 ways to use cryptocurrency to manage money – Britannica, https://www.britannica.com/money/crypto-use-cases 44. What’s Crypto Good For? Discover 6 Use Cases Changing the World – The Giving Block, https://thegivingblock.com/resources/whats-crypto-good-for-discover-6-use-cases-changing-the-world/ 45. Popular Cryptocurrencies & Their Use Cases – Caleb & Brown, https://calebandbrown.com/blog/types-of-crypto/ 46. Five use cases of cryptocurrencies — Bitpanda Academy, https://www.bitpanda.com/academy/en/lessons/five-use-cases-of-cryptocurrencies 47. The Lightning Network: Expanding Bitcoin Use Cases – Fidelity Digital Assets, https://www.fidelitydigitalassets.com/research-and-insights/lightning-network-expanding-bitcoin-use-cases 48. Crypto Use Cases: 12 Real-World Stories – Bitwise, https://bitwiseinvestments.com/crypto-market-insights/crypto-use-cases-12-real-world-stories 49. New research highlights what drives investment in regulated Bitcoin …, https://business.fiu.edu/news/2025/new-research-highlights-what-drives-investment-in-regulated-bitcoin-products.html 50. Does crypto deserve a place in portfolio construction? – Asset Management – J.P. Morgan, https://am.jpmorgan.com/us/en/asset-management/adv/insights/market-insights/market-updates/on-the-minds-of-investors/does-crypto-deserve-a-place-in-portfolio-construction/ 51. Peter Schiff’s Bitcoin Bond Secret: The Gold Bug Caught Holding ‘Digital Gold’ – Nasdaq, https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/peter-schiffs-bitcoin-bond-secret-gold-bug-caught-holding-digital-gold 52. Cryptocurrency Basics: Pros, Cons and How It Works – NerdWallet, https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/investing/cryptocurrency 53. The brutal truth about Bitcoin – Brookings Institution, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-brutal-truth-about-bitcoin/ 54. Debunked: What Truly Gives Bitcoin Its Value? – OSL, https://osl.com/academy/article/debunked-what-truly-gives-bitcoin-its-value 55. Bitcoin Price, BTC Price, Live Charts, and Marketcap – Coinbase, https://www.coinbase.com/price/bitcoin 56. BTC USD — Bitcoin Price and Chart – TradingView, https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/BTCUSD/ 57. Bitcoin’s Price History – Investopedia, https://www.investopedia.com/articles/forex/121815/bitcoins-price-history.asp 58. Bitcoin Volatility Explained: Causes, Trends & Trading Strategies | Caleb & Brown, https://calebandbrown.com/blog/bitcoin-volatility/ 59. Bitcoin Volatility Guide: Trends & Insights for Investors | iShares …, https://www.ishares.com/us/insights/bitcoin-volatility-trends 60. A Closer Look at Bitcoin’s Volatility – Fidelity Digital Assets, https://www.fidelitydigitalassets.com/research-and-insights/closer-look-bitcoins-volatility 61. Bitcoin Price Phases: Navigating Bitcoin’s Volatility Trends – Fidelity Digital Assets, https://www.fidelitydigitalassets.com/research-and-insights/bitcoin-price-phases-navigating-bitcoins-volatility-trends